Does the Evidence Support the Argument?
Free to teach as-is — the teacher guide, student handout, and slides are included.
Free — we'll email you an access link. Google Docs format.
Objective
I can determine if the evidence an author uses supports their argument.
Part 1 of 4
Warm-up video
Snap Language · 6:26
We don't generate video — this one is by Snap Language on YouTube. The practice questions and exit ticket below were drafted by AI for this objective, and every question is editable in the teacher guide.
Part 2 of 4
Key concepts
3 concepts
- 1
When analyzing an argument, it is important to evaluate whether the evidence is relevant and sufficient.
- 2
An argument presents a series of claims that lead to a conclusion, and the premises must support the conclusion in a logical way.
- 3
When evaluating evidence, ask yourself: Did the author present sufficient information? Is all the information relevant to the conclusion?
Part 3 of 4
Practice
9 questions
What does it mean for evidence to be 'relevant' in the context of an argument?
Why is it important to evaluate the evidence presented in an argument?
Part 4 of 4
Exit ticket
Quick comprehension check
“An author argues that hybrid cars are better for the environment. They state that hybrid cars use less gas. Is this evidence relevant to the author's argument? Explain why or why not.”
Sample answer included in the free materials
Get the materials
Teacher guide, student handout, and slides — free, in Google Docs format
Teacher Guide
Complete lesson plan with answer keys and alternate activities
Student Handout
Printable worksheet
Slides
Ready to present
We'll ask for your email to send your access link — nothing else.
Teaching a group at a different level?
Where are your students right now? We'll rebuild this lesson to match — including the teacher guide, student handout, and slides, saved to your Google Drive.
Adapt This Lesson